A MODERN TRAIL OF TEARS

By Ann Menasche

This piece is the opinion of the author and does not necessarily represent the opinion of FIST as an organization.

The United States knows quite a bit about genocide and ethnic cleansing.  In the 1830’s, 60,000 Native Americans – the Cherokee and other tribes – were forcibly removed from their homeland in the Southern U.S and forced into reservations. About 16,000 died during this forced exile hundreds of miles to Oklahoma, from disease, starvation, and exposure to the elements in what became known as the “Trail of Tears.”  It was fundamentally a land grab by white settlers with the support of the U.S. government.  And it was genocide, though the concept didn’t really exist until the modern era.

Since 1948, genocide has been defined as “acts committed with the intent to destroy in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group.”  The acts include killing, causing serious harm, inflicting conditions of life to destroy a group, preventing births, and forcibly transferring children.

How little humanity has learned since the original Trial of Tears of two centuries ago. We are now seeing unfolding in real time on our screens the destruction in whole or in part of the Palestinians of Gaza.   More tonnage of bombs has been dropped on Gaza than at Hiroshima, with at least 60,000 dead, mostly women and children, with many more buried in the rubble.  The large majority of housing, schools, hospitals, mosques, civilian infrastructure, all that is necessary to sustain life, has been destroyed.  Even seeking the pittance of food aid that Israel allows into Gaza, can risk one’s life from sniper fire, as already hundreds have been killed in this gruesome fashion. Palestinians, left hungry and homeless,  have been herded from north to south and back again with no safe place to go.  And now with the attack and threatened occupation of Gaza City, there is virtually nothing left.

Israeli finance minister Bezalei Smotrich has shamelessly stated the purpose of this killing spree. He described Gaza as a potential real estate “bonanza”, claiming he was talking to the U.S. about dividing up the spoils.  “We have done the demolition phase, which is always the first phase of urban renewal – now we need to build.”  https://www.cnn.com/2025/09/18/middleeast/israel-smotrich-gaza-land-intl?cid=ios_app

So, they come in packed cars, or on foot carrying a few belongings, children carrying smaller children in their arms, tens of thousands leaving Gaza City and traveling many long miles filled with pain and despair. Others, without the funds or health to leave or fearing they are being offered a road to nowhere, constituting most of the residents, are still in the City awaiting their fate.

Meanwhile, the bombs keep falling, there is not enough food or water or medical equipment.  It’s a modern trail of tears.

So, what does genocide have to do with feminism?  Let’s be clear – to destroy a people you need to destroy the women.  Women are half the human race, but also the bearers of new life.    Though women are perfectly capable of fighting and being violent, war is still overwhelming men’s business, run by rich powerful men, the generals, the macho leaders of imperial nations like Trump and Netanyahu, the war profiteers, the real estate developers with their spread sheets, all motivated by greed and narrow self-interest.  Genocide is the epitome of patriarchy, of power over, of male violence on the largest scale imaginable. So that women as non-combatants are targeted is no surprise.

There is no justification for genocide, the demonization and collective punishment of a whole population, not ever.  It does not make anyone safe against the vengeful violence of oppressed or subordinated men.  Quite the opposite. Only peace with justice does that. Native Americans also engaged in what is called “terrorism” against white settlers.  No, it did not justify the Trail of Tears.  Israeli Jews have begun to understand that, with tens of thousands demanding an end to the war and recognizing that their government does not give a damn about the fate of the hostages or the lives of their soldiers to be sacrificed in a land grab and on the altar of forever war.  That so many feminists in the United States and the U.K. don’t comprehend this is more than distressing; it is heartbreaking.

As a Jew, part of my ancestry goes back to ancient Canaan.  Palestinians are my cousins.  As a feminist, the women of Gaza are my sisters.  I share their tears. Enough.

 

 

 

 

 

NO TO NO PLATFORMING – YES TO OPEN DISCUSSION IN THE MOVEMENT

By Ann Menasche

This piece represents the views of the author and does not necessarily represent those of FIST as an organization.

I just learned that Julia Beck was prevented from leading a workshop on compulsory heterosexuality at the Filia Women’s Rights Conference because she spoke at a forum on gender identity at the Heritage Foundation back in 2019.  As someone who was critical of the decision by some feminists to participate in this far Right stridently anti-feminist venue (as were many other FIST members), I believe that “no platforming” someone within the feminist movement is not the way to go.  We need more discussion and debate, not less.

Ironically, Julia has rethought many of her views on this issue and is now a lot closer to my own way of thinking, which has also undergone some evolution.  See Julia’s substack essay, Public Statement on working with the right, part 2: Critique and analysis. At that time, I saw two problems with close collaboration with the Right and felt that participation at the Heritage Foundation event held far more negatives than positives for feminists.  One problem is that it discredited our movement, feeding into the idea that being critical of gender identity ideology is inherently “Right-wing.”  Second, is that these alliances disoriented and disarmed feminists into thinking those in the Right are our friends, and led to minimizing the importance of fundamental feminist issues like abortion rights, the Equal Rights Amendments and lesbian rights (which the Right opposes), and that of the movement being anti-racist, anti-imperialist, etc.   My position on this hasn’t changed. Clearly, feminists have two organized and powerful enemies, not one.  Both support and shore-up patriarchy.

Part of the problem, and here Julia and I somewhat disagree, is considering the Democratic Party as “the Left” when it is nothing of the kind.  I have rejected “lesser evilism” most of my life. With so many feminists and progressives following the lead of the Democratic Party – the Party of war and austerity, like the Republicans – has led to allowing the Democratic Party leadership to set the agenda and define for us what it means to be “on the Left.”   That led to the widespread acceptance by progressives of a regressive ideology that denies sex, pushes women and gays and lesbians back, and does permanent physical harm to gender non-conforming and traumatized children.

Moreover, supporting the “lesser evil” has led those focused on the single issue of gender identity to support Trump, and ignore the dangers of Project 2025 for the status of women.  Feminism cannot be restricted to single issue, because the oppression of women is complex and multi-faceted.  Just recognizing that sex exists, as essential as that is to be able to organize and fight for our rights as a sex-class, hardly solves the problem.  The Taliban knows what a woman is.

But I agree with Julia that rigid dogmatism is not the answer.  I have attended and spoken at an event opposing child “gender transition” which had Right wing participation, though I wouldn’t characterize the protest itself as “Right”.  I spoke openly as a member of FIST and a socialist.  I would likewise participate in actions and support bills to stop U.S. support for the Israeli genocide against the people of Gaza though Marjorie Taylor Green, whose politics I generally despise, has also taken such a stand or may be co-sponsoring such bills.   I decide my position on issues and bills on their own merits.

Most importantly, our movement must remain democratic and open to a range of views on these issues.  All of us learn and grow from discussion and debate.  No-platforming feminists, even where we strongly disagree with them on issues of tactics and strategy, is an authoritarian method that has no place in the feminist movement.

 

 

Radical Feminists Advance at National NOW Conference

By Butch Barbie

NOW held its annual membership conference in Las Vegas July 10-13.  The conference was hybrid, with elections and plenaries streaming on Zoom.  Issue hearings and workshops were also held but not streamed to virtual attendees.

For the first time in recent memory, a caucus of radical feminists pushed 2 resolutions through issue hearings for a vote by the membership.  A third resolution passed by petition with 35 signatures. The group was surprised that the resolutions passed were the most ‘controversial’—Single Sex Prisons and Online Age Verification for Pornography through the issue hearings, and Lesbian Only Spaces by petition.  The next step would have been a floor vote by the members on Sunday, the last day of the conference.

Unfortunately that day never came.  Elections were held for a new President and Vice President on Saturday afternoon.  Normally the candidates are advised of the results Saturday evening and officially announced Sunday morning.  Instead, Sunday morning the conference was cancelled by parliamentarian Lynette Henley, who stood on stage with Elections Committee co-chair Rosa Colquitt and outgoing VP Bear Atwood.  Citing unnamed (and still unproven) ‘third parties’ interfering with the election, and lack of quorum (untrue and quorum was not challenged), Henley declared the conference void.  Atwood then adjourned the conference.

This unexpected turn of events was met with outrage by those present and online as well.  When a board member challenged the Parliamentarian, she was screamed at and threatened by VP Candidate Triana Arnold James to keep away.  Members ended up gathering for strategy sessions which continued for 2 weeks.

After a secret board meeting convened by outgoing President Christian Nunes who falsely claimed the election was hacked, the Election Committee finally revealed the results of the officer election. The winning slate with 76.9% of the vote was Kim Villanueva for President and Rose Brunache for Vice President.  Rose is a young African American radical feminist from the Washington DC chapter.  Kim, an out Latina lesbian from Illinois, is a longstanding NOW member who has served at nearly every level in the organization and is willing to open up dialogue on our issues.

As for the resolutions, the normal procedure is for the national board to vote on them at their next meeting if they hadn’t been voted on at the conference.  Since nothing was normal about this conference, we will have to wait until the September board meeting to see what happens.

 

 

Trump Administration is Destroying Feminist Infrastructure Built Over Decades

(This contribution is the opinion of the author and does not necessarily represent the opinions of Feminists in Struggle. Stay tune for further discussion and FIST action on this important topic.)

The Trump Administration is destroying the governmental infrastructure that supports feminism–and that was brought into being by decades of feminist struggle.

Social change begins with protest in the streets and gradually moves its way through courts and legislatures to become law. The new laws are administered by government departments that disburse funding for programs mandated by these laws–which often are administered by a web of not-for-profit organizations. As the Trump Administration has moved to dismantle entire government departments, the programs these Departments oversee and that were approved by Congress as a result of much political labor by women and others, are now being defunded, with staff fired and told their work is “not in keeping with the priorities of this Administration”. The fruits of much struggle–including feminist struggle are disappearing.

As just one example: in February, 2025, non-profits that set up and administer shelters for victims of domestic violence, mandated in the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) administered by the Office of Violence Against Women (part of the the Department of Justice/DOJ), found that the funds they annually rely on to keep going had been put “on hold” indefinitely. This was as a result of Diversity/Equity/Inclusion programs (DEI) being no longer allowed–with ‘special’ shelters for women being thus classified. VAWA programs are also being defunded because Trump is dismantling the entire DOJ and shrinking it down to being merely a tool of vengeance against his ‘enemies’. Thus, one of the fruits of feminism that started with Consciousness Raising groups of women in the 1960’s discussing violence from men in their lives and then starting a movement to stop it–has been stripped of any government funding and its functioning eliminated.

The Trump Administration has also announced its intention of dismantling the Department of Education (DOE), which is critical for women’s equality in the entire educational system. The DOE oversees equal sports facilities for males and females (under Title 9 of the Civil Rights Act of 1964–added in 1972); it investigates sexual harassment and assault in government funded (public) schools and has its own Office of Civil Rights (OCR) for this purpose; it works toward girls getting educated in STEM/digital literacy subjects and distributes Pell grants so that education is not limited by poverty (girls and women get 62% of these). There are currently over 1,000 complaints of sexual harassment in the pipeline that will now never be investigated because of the dismantling of the DOE (not to mention the girls now being harassed who have no place to turn). If Trump gets his way and all education is administered by the states, you can bet that most will not have these protections for women! And even in the ‘good’ states, it will all have to be fought for over again.

Trump’s attempts to make all aspects of Affirmative Action/DEI illegal, if successful (there are many court cases opposing his attempt) will have a great impact on women, who have largely benefited from these programs. This includes the end of ‘set asides’ in government contracts for historically disadvantaged people such as racial minorities and women; it will change the composition of students on campuses and will remove the legal ‘scaffolding’ women and people of color have used to get ahead in a world where, through generational disadvantage and plain old bias, they have been–and still are–at a disadvantage. At present, the word “women” has been flagged as making grant seekers ineligible for government grants who use this word in their proposals!

There is much more happening to dismantle feminism and all of its objectives in the present nascent fascist Trump Administration than I have space to describe here.

I believe that even as we fight the harms of gender ideology, we MUST keep in mind that everything else that feminists have fought for is under attack by the Trump Administration. Women may argue about which is the greater evil, but I believe that many gender critical women are ignoring or rationalizing Trump’s present and future actions against us, because he has supported some of our gender critical positions (there being only two sexes, etc.).

Given the larger ideology of the Christian Right (see Project 2025, the ideal of ‘biblical marriage’ and the ‘place of women’), the naked male supremacy of this administrations and the ongoing attacks on the infrastructure of feminism,  ‘statements of support’ from the Trump Administration are a ‘Trojan Horse’ and we must not be fooled

It would be extremely ironic if we finally got men out of women’s sport and out of DV shelters, only to find that there was no more women’s sport and no more DV Shelters due to their having been defunded by our new right wing ‘friends’.

 

 

TALE OF TWO WITCH-HUNTS

By Ann Menasche

(This piece is the opinion of the author and does not necessarily represent the opinions of Feminists in Struggle)

Feminists are quite familiar with the witch-hunt against so-called “TERFS”, women who assert that sex exists, and is immutable, and the female half of humanity (including lesbians, as women who love women), are deserving of rights based on our sex.  Such recognition that women are a discrete group of people with our own rights and needs (including our right to privacy and safety and to organize apart from males) and indeed, that we are members of the oppressed sex still living under millennia of male supremacy, used to be a no-brainer for progressives and anyone who considered themselves part of the Left.  Then historical amnesia set in and a new catechism, that “transwomen are women”, trickled down from the powers-that-be making a fortune off the bodies of gay, gender non-conforming and/or traumatized children and young people in the “sex change” industry.  Before long, they succeeded in labelling anyone who disagreed as “transphobic” – not ordinary “bigots,” mind you, (with whom you might still be able to have a civil discussion) but the equivalent of “Nazis.”

I have experienced the trauma of the witch-hunt personally – fired from my civil rights job of 20 years, excluded from my local chapter of Jewish Voice for Peace, told that neither my name nor face were welcome in Jill Stein’s Green Party Presidential Campaign, and more recently prevented from renewing my membership in a professional network of homeless lawyers.  All because I have spoken out publicly about women’s sex-based rights. There are many other women who have had their livelihoods and community work similarly jeopardized and even their physical safety threatened, courageous women like Amy Hamm in Canada, a nurse, found to have committed professional misconduct for her outside feminist activities and then fired; also, Kathleen Stock in the U.K., Thistle Pettersen in Wisconsin and Christy Hammer in Maine, to name just a few.

Like all witch-hunts, this one creates an atmosphere of fear and intimidation, dissuading others from speaking out. Some have even felt compelled to denounce the “witches” in order not to be accused of engaging in witchcraft themselves.  Like the scapegoating of old, including the Red Scare of the 1940’s and 50’s targeting anyone suspected of communism or communist sympathies, the ostracism meted against these women is often all-encompassing.  It means that you are blacklisted, no-platformed, removed from the community.

It doesn’t matter if the issue never came up in your job or professional work; your “thought crimes” expressed on social media, in your private life or in outside political activities is enough to hang you.  Your very presence, (the magic power of the “evil eye,” no doubt), makes others “unsafe.”

Since it was only feminists affected, for a long time, no one paid much attention to this witch-hunt.  (That may be changing in the UK with a significant feminist fight-back culminating in the UK Supreme Court decision agreeing that woman means woman under law, and that single sex spaces and programs for women and girls must be protected.)

But now a far bigger more dramatic witch-hunt is brewing in the U.S. and Europe, targeting both men and women, especially non-citizens legally in the country, but citizens as well, using a strikingly similar playbook as that used against feminists. In the U.S. this witch-hunt is being orchestrated by the federal government, first by the Biden administration, and now with far greater intensity, under Trump.

The “witches” this time are pro-Palestinian activists on campuses, labelled “antisemitic” haters for their opposition to Israeli genocide in Gaza, whose political opinions and very presence supposedly make Jewish students “unsafe.”  Never mind that many Jews agree with and have participated in the protests and that even in Israel, a growing number of Jews are demanding, in the streets  of Jerusalem and Tel Aviv, an end to the slaughter. In Columbia University, numerous students have been expelled, suspended or stripped of their degrees for exercise of First Amendment rights to speak and peacefully protest against Israel and U.S. foreign policy.  Professors too have been arrested and targeted for peacefully registering their dissent.

For legal permanent resident Mahmoud Khalil, this witch-hunt has meant detention by immigration agents and attempts to deport him, though he has never been charged with any crime. Nor has any evidence been produced that he was antisemitic or even pro-Hamas.  In witch-hunts, evidence is besides the point.

None of this is ever about anyone’s safety, but about silencing speech and preventing critical thought.

Freedom of speech and assembly is for everyone or for no one.  Suppression of speech and thought, whether through government-led repression or by groups claiming to be “progressive” while targeting others’ jobs and livelihoods and ostracizing them from the community for their “wrong” opinions, makes all of us less safe.  We never know who will be the next “witch.”

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

.

 

 

FEMINISTS IN STRUGGLE MEMBERS VOTE TO ENDORSE CALIFORNIA LEGISLATION ADVANCING WOMEN’S AND CHILDREN’S RIGHTS

By a 78% vote of its membership, Feminists in Struggle voted to endorse three important pieces of proposed California legislation that would curb the extremist policies of sex denying gender identity ideologues that have dominated California’s state government.  The bills, if approved, would go a long way to securing the rights of women and girls and those of children of both sexes that have been compromised as a result of this reactionary, misogynistic and homophobic ideology.

The proposed legislation is the following:

Yaeli’s Bill: This bill  would end the despicable practice under current law of removing custody from non-abusive parents, even forcing a child into foster care, merely because a parent refuses to agree to “transition” their child.  “Transition” of minors, often involving removal of healthy body parts, and high risk of sterilization, and other permanent harms to a child’s developing body, is an unproven practice that is increasingly being rejected by the UK and Scandinavian countries that have conducted comprehensive reviews.  See the Cass Review, available for download here. [ARCHIVED CONTENT] Final Report – Cass Review  If this bill is approved, it would no longer be deemed  child abuse to refuse to socially or medically transition your child, and the refusal to transition your child will no longer be considered in custody disputes.

RN 25 03490 This bill allows parents to Opt-Out of all instructions related to transgender.  This ideology is heavily promoted in schools, teaching children tthe unscientific view that sex doesn’t exist or is a spectrum, and that some children are born in the “wrong” body and need medicalization to be themselves. The group most vulnerable to this message are children who don’t conform to sex stereotypes, most of whom are likely, if left alone, to grow up to be lesbian or gay.  Also vulnerable are autistic children who have problems fitting in and children, especially girls, who have experienced sexual abuse or other forms of male violence.

Repeal of Education Code 221.5: The proposed legislation would repeal the California law that permits students to decide changing facilities/sports teams based upon Gender Identity (all grades and college) rather than sex.  Female only sports teams are needed for fair competition and to provide equal opportunity for women and girls to develop themselves and receive equal recognition and scholarships for their athletic achievements.   Separate changing rooms for women and girls based on sex are necessary to respect their privacy and safety needs in a world where male voyeurism, exhibitionism, sexual harassment and rape are pervasive problems.  There is no evidence that males who transition are less prone to anti-woman violence than any other male.

FIST fights for a world free of male violence where women’s rights to equality, dignity, reproductive choice, and equal opportunity are respected; children’s health is protected from experimental treatments; there is no longer a stigma against same sex love; and everyone is free to dress and express themselves as they like without the sexist strait-jacket of “masculine” and “feminine” sex roles and stereotypes imposed on people based on their sex.  In other words, women’s liberation.

As we work toward such a world, we urge all our supporters to get behind these bills.

 

FIST DECLARES ITS SUPPORT FOR REEM ALSALEM, UN RAPPORTEUR ON VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN AND GIRLS

In February, 2025, Feminists in Struggle joined with over 500 organizations and 5000 individuals in signing the “Global support letter for the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women and Girls, its causes and consequences, Reem Alsalem” (1).

Ms. Reem Alsalem became the 5th person to hold the mandate as the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women and Girls (UNSRVAWG) in August of 2021.  This role was established in 1994 (resolution 1994/45) by the UN Human Rights Council (formerly the Human Rights Commission) for an independent human rights expert to specifically examine the global problem of violence against women and girls and recommend actions to end it (2).

The United Nations defines violence against women as: “any act of gender-based violence that results in, or is likely to result in, physical, sexual or psychological harm or suffering to women, including threats of such acts, coercion or arbitrary deprivation of liberty, whether occurring in public or in private life” (3).

Ms. Alsalem has been tirelessly speaking out about the systemic oppression of women and girls, state-sanctioned violence, and dramatic losses of previously held civil rights and protections occurring in countries around the world, from United States to Afghanistan.  She has refused to adopt the re-branded “newspeak” seeking to call acts of genital mutilation or prostitution by more sanitized names.   She remains steadfast and focused on the realities facing women and girls as a sex-class, within a global context.   Utilizing a radical feminist and gender critical analysis, she seeks to truly root out the  ‘causes and consequences’ of violence against women and girls and takes a strong stand on behalf of female sexual survivors, presenting groundbreaking research centering these marginalized voices within her reports.

At the 56th session of the the United Nations Human Rights Council in Geneva last June, 2024, Reem Alsalem presented her comprehensive Report on Prostitution and Violence Against Women and Girls, the first of its kind to focus solely on the consequences of prostitution on the lives of women and girls (4).  In this document, she refuses to pander to the demand to re-language prostitution as “sex work” and identifies this as an attempt to sanitize sexual exploitation by repackaging (remarketing) it as empowering to women and as a valid form of labor, just like any other job.   She sees through the attempts to frame pornography as anything other than “filmed prostitution” and above all, she highlights the voices of survivors who have exited prostitution and work toward abolition.

By focusing on the evidence offered by survivors and those who serve them “rather than ideological fervor,” her report provides a thorough review of all of the available data and research, which documents the clear and significant harms caused to women and girls involved in prostitution, pornography, and other forms of sexual exploitation – and how the normalization of these behaviors continues to support the escalation of violence against women and girls everywhere (5).

We as FIST stand with and celebrate Reem Alsalem for her work and join her and other organizations in speaking out against the propaganda campaigns of criminals and their financiers who seek to exploit, commodify, oppress, and deny basic human rights to women and girls across the world.

 

References:

  1. “Global support letter for Reem Alsalem, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women and Girls, its causes and consequences.”  Women’s Platform for Action, February 21, 2025. https://www.womensplatformforaction.org/global-support-letter/
  2. https://www.ohchr.org/en/about-mandate
  3.  http://www.un.org/womenwatch/daw/vaw/v-overview.htm
  4. Alsalem, Reem, “Prostitution and violence against women and girls: Report of the Special Rapporteur on violence against women and girls, its causes and consequences.” United Nations, Human Rights Council, Fifty-sixth session, 18 June–12 July 2024.  A/HRC/56/48*

https://documents.un.org/doc/undoc/gen/g24/078/81/pdf/g2407881.pdf

Alsalem, Reem, “Response to a Political Critique and Personal Attack Against a United Nations Report that Presented New Evidence About Prostitution as a Cause and Consequence of Violence Against Women and Girls,” Dignity: A Journal of Analysis of Exploitation and Violence: Vol. 10: Iss. 1, Article 6, 2025.  https://doi.org/10.23860/dignity.2025.10.01.06

 

THE KILLING OF DEI AND THE MYTH OF MERITOCRACY

By Ann Menasche

This article is the opinion of the author and doesn’t necessarily represent the opinions of FIST as an organization.

Many feminists breathed a big sigh of relief when President Trump issued his Executive Order on gender ideology, https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/defending-women-from-gender-ideology-extremism-and-restoring-biological-truth-to-the-federal-government/, recognizing two immutable sexes and restoring the definition of women to adult human female, without which any women’s rights, even the ERA, lose all meaning.  This has the immediate benefit of women’s bathrooms and changing rooms, prison cells and sports teams at least on the federal level being reserved once again for us alone apart from males, regardless of their gender identity.

At the same time, Trump revealed through another EO that what he had in mind for the sex class of women wasn’t exactly what we feminists have struggled for over the past century.  https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/ending-radical-and-wasteful-government-dei-programs-and-preferencing/ Instead, he sought to undermine women’s right to equal job opportunities alongside men and to return to the mythical past of a “meritocracy” where white males somehow were always the ones who managed to get ahead not of course because of the “old boys” network providing a leg up, but because they were simply the smartest and most qualified around.

Trump’s direct target was to destroy DEI (Diversity, Equity and Inclusion) programs, which he labelled “radical and wasteful”, both in the federal government and in private companies that contract with the government. DEI is the corporatized watered-down version of the robust affirmative action programs of the 1960’s, 70’s and 80’s that helped even the playing field and advance women and African Americans in all sectors of society where they had previously been excluded.  Those affirmative action programs were eroded by successful court challenges and Proposition 209 in California in 1996.

DEI, reduced to a shadow of its formal self, at times even became a caricature -removing sex as a protected class in favor of gender identity, targeting gender critical feminists and lesbians as “bigots”, and emphasizing “politically correct” language (the rules of which changed frequently), virtue signaling, avoiding micro-aggressions, and urging brow-beating and confessions of guilt, as a substitute for real meaningful measures that would provide equal opportunity to women and people of color in the workplace.  Yet DEI was the only way the white males that still dominate the workplace were forced to pay a little attention to whether they were truly the only ones capable of exercising leadership and doing a job well or whether a few Blacks, Latinos or women should be allowed that opportunity.

As anyone  knows who has looked at the research or who has opened their eyes to the dynamics in the workplace, sex and race discrimination are still widespread though difficult to prove on an individual basis.  (Employers and managers frankly don’t always tell the truth.) See https://hbr.org/2017/10/hiring-discrimination-against-black-americans-hasnt-declined-in-25-years. See also https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2017/12/14/gender-discrimination-comes-in-many-forms-for-todays-working-women/.  And it is not white males that are experiencing the brunt of the discrimination.

Yet the Trump administration is making the preposterous claim – rooted in white supremacy and male supremacy – that without DEI, there will be a meritocracy that will return us to the time where our “betters” – white males like himself- the only or best qualified, will regain their rightful place in society. He is being cheered on by people who are claiming all over social media that the problem with the Los Angeles fires arose because the Mayor and Police Chief are two “unqualified” women (one, also a person of color) rather than due to policies of austerity and the failure to maintain the fire hydrants which have nothing to do with sex or race.

The most frightening part of Trump’s actions against DEI is his mandating that people report their co-workers who violate his new DEI policy, launching a witch-hunt against anyone who is suspected of utilizing DEI. Of course, the best way to prove one’s innocence is to never hire or promote women or people of color in the first place.

It is essential for women’s existence as a sex to be recognized, but obviously, it is not the whole enchilada.  WE WANT EQUALITY! And affirmative action is a necessary part of getting us there.

 

 

EDUCATIONAL PROGRAM PLANNED FOR SATURDAY FEBRUARY 1st: THE TRUTH ABOUT PEDIATRIC “GENDER AFFIRMING CARE” FEATURING WHISTLEBLOWER JAMIE REED

Feminists In Struggle is proud to host JAMIE REED who will be providing an in depth educational presentation on Zoom about so-called “Gender Affirming Care” for minor children and its life-long negative impacts on them.  

The Educational event will take place on Saturday, February 1st at 11:00 a.m. Pacific time/2:00 p.m. Eastern time.

TICKETS AVAILABLE HERE: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/feminist-educational-the-truth-about-gender-affirming-care-for-minors-tickets-1114924201299?aff=oddtdtcreator

Jamie is one of the first public whistleblowers from a pediatric gender clinic in the United States. Her explosive first person account, “I thought I was saving trans kids, Now I am blowing the whistle” was published in The Free Press in February 2023. The story traveled the globe.

Jamie is now the Executive Director and Co-Founder of the Courage Coalition, an American based nonprofit of lesbians and gay male adults seeking to reform youth gender medicine. The Courage Coalition seeks to impact culture and medicine to accept and support gender non-conformity in a non-medicalized way. Jamie recently spoke on the steps of the United States Supreme Court at a rally on the day of the US v Skrmetti oral arguments.

Jamie is an accomplished public speaker and has been interviewed and profiled in The New York Times, the podcast Triggernometry, Gender: A Wider Lens, and Transparency. She has spoken at numerous conferences including Genspect: The Bigger Picture in Colorado, at the International Perspectives on Evidence- Based Treatment for Gender-Dysphoric Youth in New York, and Psychotherapeutic Process with Young People Experiencing Gender Dysphoria in Tampere, Finland.

Jamie is a lesbian and foster and adoptive parent of five boys. She holds a Master of Science in Clinical Research from Washington University in St. Louis and a bachelor’s degree in Cultural Anthropology.

Feminists in Struggle’s forums and educational events are interactive, encouraging questions and participation from the audience. This special event is open to both men and women; however, women will be given priority during the discussion segment of the event.

 

 

 

FIST establishes collaboration with LGBT Courage Coalition in Campaign to End Child Transition

On November 20, 2024, three members of FIST’s Coordinating Committee and an additional FIST member met with Jamie Reed and Lauren Leggieri of the LGBT Courage Coalition to plan joint work to stop the misogynist and homophobic practice of child medical transition.  That practice targets for sterilization and permanent medical harm mostly girls and gender non-conforming children, the large majority of whom are likely to grow up to be lesbians or gay men.

We all agreed about the importance of challenging mainstream LGBT organizations that promote this practice in the name of the LGB community and that the voices of gender critical lesbians and gay men are particularly vital in this struggle.

The common work we outlined at the meeting includes:

  • Participation at the December 4th “Do No Harm” rally in front of the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington, D.C..  That day the Court will hear oral arguments in the case of United States v. Skrmetti, on the issue of whether state bans on so-called “gender affirming care” for transgender identified minors are unconstitutional.  FIST members and supporters on the east coast in particular should consider attending this important protest!
  • Participation in protests at medical conferences planned for the spring and summer of 2025 in Los Angeles and San Francisco.  Stay tuned for details!
  • Educating FIST members and our periphery on the effect of puberty blockers on developing adolescents and the other permanent harms associated with these “treatments”.

All of us in FIST look forward to working together with the LGBT Courage Coalition in the coming months!